Organic Dairy Farming: Benefits and Challenges


Over the past few decades, organic farming has gained tremendous popularity all over the world. While conventional farming relies heavily on the use of synthetic chemicals and hormones, organic farming is a more natural and sustainable approach that produces healthier food and takes better care of our environment. Dairy farming is no exception to this trend. More and more dairy farmers are transitioning to organic practices to reap the many benefits of this farming method. At the same time, going organic also poses certain unique challenges that need to be overcome. In this article, I will discuss some of the major benefits of organic dairy farming as well as the challenges faced by organic dairy farmers. I hope this information provides useful insights for those considering the organic option or supporting organic dairy producers.

Benefits of Organic Dairy Farming

Healthier cows and healthier milk: One of the biggest advantages of organic dairy farming is that the animals are raised according to their natural needs without any synthetic hormones or chemicals. Organic dairy cows are given organic feed that is free from pesticides, antibiotics, and GMOs. As a result, their milk is also free from antibiotics, synthetic hormones like rBST, and other contaminants. This makes organic milk a much healthier option for both humans and calves. Studies have shown that organically raised cows have stronger immune systems and are less susceptible to diseases than conventionally farmed cows. Their milk contains higher levels of beneficial omega-3s as well.

Better profits from premium prices: Organically produced milk commands a significantly higher price in the market compared to conventional milk. According to recent studies, organic milk receives approximately $1-3/gallon more compared to conventional milk. These premium organic prices allow dairy farmers to recoup some of the additional costs involved in organic production and operations. The growing demand and stable organic premium prices also provide more financial security to organic dairy farming businesses. Many farms have found that transitioning to organic production enhances the long-term profitability and viability of their operations.

Environmentally sustainable practices: Organic dairy farms follow rigorous standards that promote environmental stewardship and sustainability. Synthetic fertilizers and pesticides are prohibited which reduces pollution from agricultural runoff. Organic farms rely more on rotational grazing and pasture-based systems. This allows the cows to produce milk in healthier, more natural living conditions while benefiting soil quality, biodiversity, and watersheds. Nutrient cycling is also better as organic manure is used to replenish soil fertility. Overall, organic dairy farming is aligned with protecting environmental resources for future generations.

Stronger rural communities: Organic dairy production helps strengthen rural communities by supporting local agricultural economies and providing meaningful employment opportunities on family farms. Organic standards require pasture access for ruminants. This in turn promotes more distributed pasture-based grazing systems versus large confinement operations. Small and mid-sized organic dairy farms are an important economic driver and foundation for thriving small towns across America. By choosing organic, consumers can vote with their dollars to preserve these valued rural livelihoods and landscapes.

Improved animal welfare: As caretakers of living creatures, most organic dairy farmers take pride in providing for the health and well-being of their herds. Cows on organic farms receive compassionate treatment with access to deep bedded freestalls, pastures, and protection from stressors like overcrowding. Organic standards strictly prohibit tail docking, growth hormones, and other questionable conventional practices. The cows are selective fed organically grown fodder and rotated between pastures to ensure their natural and humane housing. This leads to healthier, happier animals that can better express their natural behaviors.

Challenges of Organic Dairy Farming

Higher costs of production: While organic operations save on certain synthetic inputs, transitioning to organics and maintaining certification entails additional costs that can pressure profit margins. Organic feed, particularly high quality forages, often costs more. Additional labor may be needed for pasture management,weed and pest control using natural methods. Fertility building and composting practices also require extra time and resources. Meeting complex organic standards demands careful record keeping and inspection costs. These increased expenses pose initial challenges but can pay off long term with organic price premiums.

Weed, pest and disease management issues: Without conventional chemicals, organic farmers must rely on preventive practices and organic approved methods for controlling weeds, insect pests and pathogens. This multi-pronged systems approach takes more planning and effort to implement effectively on a working farm. It can be difficult to stay ahead of emerging issues without synthetic tools. Strong record keeping proves management strategies. Building healthy, biologically active soil takes time and the transition period may see pest pressure increase before achieving balance.

Demand and market development: As a smaller market segment, securing organic dairy contracts and fair pricing can be challenging. Processor demand and retail shelf space still lag behind the increased supply of organic milk. Farmers report difficulties negotiating contracts and lack of consistent year-round organic premium rates. Developing processing infrastructure, distribution channels and export markets continues to be an ongoing effort for the organic industry. Weathering market fluctuations requires resilience from farmers.

Finding and retaining labor: With grazing and handling animals primarily by hand, organic dairies tend to need more manual labor than confinement operations. However, finding reliable workers willing to take on physical chores outside in all weather conditions proves difficult in many rural locations. Developing on-farm jobs that offer fair wages, training and career advancement opportunities helps attract and keep skilled help long term. Farming is not easy work but adequate support systems make it more appealing to potential employees.

Transition challenges: Converting to organic production presents major adjustment challenges. Livestock and crops must be managed without prohibited substances for a full 36 months before harvest or milk from those animals can be certified organic and receive premium pricing. This lengthy transition period puts significant financial strain on farms. Herd health issues are more likely to occur as animals adjust to their new non-GMO organic diets without synthetic treatments. Yields may fall initially before soil health and management practices catch up. Navigating the transition takes patience and plenty of perseverance during a potentially unprofitable timeframe.

The challenge is how to make 'Dairy Farming' environmentally viable - JK  Policy Institute | Research, Policy, Development, Governance

Potential solutions to organic dairy challenges

Higher input costs can potentially be offset by adopting additional strategies like:

  • Rotational grazing to reduce purchased feed needs by optimizing homegrown forages
  • On-farm composting to build soil fertility from manure, minimizing purchased fertilizer needs
  • Efficient harvest of rainfall through swales and pasture infrastructure to reduce irrigation costs
  • Community supported agriculture programs where consumers pre-pay for a portion of the farm's annual production offer guaranteed income

Effective integrated pest management programs can help control weeds, pests and diseases through preventive practices like:

  • Crop rotations and habitat plantings to foster beneficial insect populations
  • Grazing livestock to manage pasture weeds by continuous cropping
  • Sanitation and manure management to prevent disease issues
  • Careful scouting and record-keeping to promptly address any emerging problems naturally

To help counter market challenges, farms can diversify their business model with:

  • On-farm aging and artisan products utilizing whole milk to boost value-added sales
  • Direct marketing through farm stands, home delivery and participation in farmers markets
  • Community partnerships for CSAs, ‘adopt a cow’ programs, and agritourism experiences to develop consumer relationships

Addressing the labor issue involves:

  • Offering attractive housing, meals or cost of living stipends
  • Establishing wages above minimum and paid time off benefits
  • Mentoring new employees and providing advancement opportunities for longtime workers

Transition stresses may be eased by:

  • Building transition herds from already organically raised livestock when possible
  • Gradually converting crop and pasture acres over 3-5 years vs. all at once
  • Consulting experienced organic farmers and certifiers throughout the process
  • Seeking organic transition support programs from state and nonprofit sources

The organic option presents worthwhile opportunities for dairy farms but successfully overcoming these challenges requires diligent planning, community partnerships and resilience through market fluctuations. With concerted efforts across the supply chain and public policy support, the promising growth trajectory of organic dairy farming can continue.

Certification Process

Dairy farms wishing to become certified organic must work with a USDA accredited certifying agency. This involves developing an organic system plan and undergoing an annual inspection process. There is also mandatory record keeping to show compliance with standards.

Pasture Requirements

Organic ruminant livestock like cows must graze on pasture during the grazing season, which is at least 120 days per year. 30% of their dry matter intake must come from pasture overall. This ensures farms maintain grazing land.

Feed Standards

Organically certified feed for dairy cows must be free of synthetics like antibiotics, hormones and pesticides. It primarily consists of organic grain mixes and forages like hay grown without prohibited substances. GMOs are not allowed in organic feed rations.

Mastitis Management

Without antibiotics, organic dairy farmers rely more on preventative measures and alternative therapies to treat mastitis infections in cows. Nutraceuticals, homeopathy, and enhancing cow comfort/hygiene through barn design features are examples of natural strategies used.

Breed Selection

Some organic producers choose cattle breeds well-suited to hardy pasture-based living, like Jerseys and Guernseys, which are smaller framed and known for temperate dispositions. Heritage/dual-purpose breeds may also be selected for their ability to graze diverse forages.

Profitability Factors

While premium organic prices help financial viability, factors like herd health, pasture quality/management, feeding costs, and successful transition planning greatly impact profitability on organic dairy farms versus conventional operations.

Consumer Trends

Growing numbers of environmentally-conscious consumers are seeking sustainably-produced local foods that support ethical farmers. This demographic shift benefits organic dairy producers and the rural communities they operate within.


What are the main differences between organic and conventional dairy farming?

The key differences are that organic dairy farms do not use synthetic hormones like rBST or antibiotics on their cows. They also rely on organic feed that is produced without genetically modified ingredients, pesticides or other prohibited substances. Organic cows spend more time on pasture and living outdoors versus confined feedlot systems used by many conventional dairies.

How much more do organic dairy farmers get paid for their milk?

Organic dairy farmers typically receive a sizable premium for their milk, usually $1-3 more per gallon compared to conventional milk prices. However, the exact organic premium can vary depending on market conditions and contracts negotiated with processors. On average, organic dairy operations earn around 20-30% higher milk prices.

What types of costs are higher for organic dairy farms?

Higher costs for organic dairy farms are primarily associated with organic feed which is often more expensive than conventional alternatives. Labor costs may also be higher due to more manual chores involved with pasture-based systems. Organic certification and compliance also adds inspection and record keeping fees. Transitioning conventional herds and land to organic also requires significant initial investment.

How do organic dairy farmers deal with weed, pest and disease problems without chemicals?

They rely on preventative practices like maintaining pasture diversity, using beneficial insect habitats and adopting integrated pest management strategies. These can include techniques like crop rotation, sanitation practices, selecting disease-resistant varieties and employing manual/mechanical controls as needed. Diligent record keeping proves proper management is occurring.

Is the demand for organic dairy products growing?

Yes, demand for organic dairy has experienced steady growth of around 15% per year according to USDA data as more consumers look for rBGH-free and pesticide-free milk options. Continued expansion of both domestic and international markets will help support more dairy farms transitioning to organic production methods.

What challenges exist during the transition to organic certification?

One of the toughest challenges is the 36 month transition period when conventional and organic crops/livestock cannot be commingled. Yields may be lower and management issues more likely to occur as herds adjust to organic feeds/systems without prohibited substances acting as "crutches." Careful planning minimizes risks but transition is a lengthy test of commitment that not all farms complete successfully.


While organic dairy farming poses unique economic and production challenges compared to conventional operations, it also provides meaningful benefits for animal welfare, public health, and environmental sustainability. By adopting best organic practices and continual problem solving approach, dedicated dairy farmers are able overcome obstacles to reap rewards including higher and more stable milk prices paid by consumers increasingly concerned about how their food is grown. With policy support, market development, and cooperation between all stakeholders in the organic sector, the future remains bright for this values-based form of dairy production to better serve both agricultural communities and society as a whole. Transitioning to organics is not a simple task but for many farms it represents an important step towards a brighter tomorrow.

Back to blog